Thursday 24 January 2008

MacBook Air Reviews

Reviews for the McAir are starting to pop up, with my favorite quote so far from Walt Mossberg, the Wall Street Journal's respected technology / gadget columnist.  He says:

"It's impossible to convey in words just how pleasing and surprising this computer feels in the hand. It's so svelte when closed that it's a real shock to discover the big screen and keyboard inside."

He does go on to mention some of the compromises made by Steve & Co to produce this small wonderMacBook_Air_back_440.jpg, but that will only put off certain classes of users.  He mentions frequent travellers as an example, but the main problem he sites is the lack of a replaceable battery.  Surely it must be possible to have an external battery working through the MagSafe connector?  That will solve that problem.

Additionally, I really don't use the optical drive on my notebook (a hefty Dell XPS) very often, and would happily go without.  Al programs I need are available on the network / web.

The key figures I'm waiting for though, are benchmarks that show the battery life improvement and performance improvement of using the SSD (solid-state drive).  The lack of moving parts should help the battery, and seek / load times should be faster, but no info has been released yet.

Another excellent quote comes from David Pogue, occasional columnist for the New York Times.  He says:

"It's a stunningly beautiful aluminum slab, three-quarters of an inch thick. Its edges are beveled to look even thinner. When it's on a table, you might mistake this laptop for a placemat."

and

"But for anyone who shares Apple's admiration for elegance, the trade-off is worth it. This laptop's cool aluminum skin and smooth edges make it ridiculously satisfying to hold, carry, open and close. You can't take your eyes or your hands off it."

Personally, I can't wait to get my hands on one, even though I've been a long-standing Microsoft supporter.  This thing is just too darn sexy :) 

The WSJ review can be found here.

The NYT comments can be found here.

No comments: